What Our Customers Say

Our agency is built on positive customer experiences. We aim to empower ministries in Wisconsin to fulfill their missions through outstanding service from our agency. That's why we think it's important that you hear from some of our customers so you can see what that means to them.

"Our American Church Group of Wisconsin agent is always available to answer any and all of our questions. We recently told him that we are considering purchasing a bus for our church, and he directed me to several helpful resources on Brotherhood Mutual’s website related to this topic. We couldn’t be happier with the excellent service, great resources, and information that we receive from our agent and Brotherhood Mutual."

Barb Schoenherr, Office Manager, Wausau Alliance Church


"American Church Group of Wisconsin’s ministry security seminar in April was the best I have attended. It led us to revise our emergency procedures, using resources from the website. We consider them a real partner in our ministry."

Bill Horvath, Executive Director of Operations, Woodlands Church


"Our coverage through American Church Group of Wisconsin gives us the peace of mind that should a catastrophe occur, our ministry could continue to function without missing a beat."

Joan Points, Administrative Coordinator, Forest Springs Camp & Conference Center


"Our American Church Group of Wisconsin agent, Larry Clinton, is friendly, professional, efficient, caring, and does his very best to help us. Each time we start a new church, I call Larry and he helps our new church leaders work through the details of insurance coverage to ensure each new ministry is properly covered. I highly recommend American Church Group of Wisconsin and Brotherhood Mutual."

Mark Millman, Church Planter Strategist/Director of Missions, Southern Wisconsin Baptist Association         


"One of the trickiest parts of being a ministry and a business is knowing what we can and cannot say. As a faith-based childcare center, we find it critical that our staff has the freedom to share about God's love and His relationship with us. Our American Church Group of Wisconsin agent clarified any questions we had and recommended other services that may be helpful for our Center. The insurance coverage they offer through Brotherhood Mutual gives us peace of mind and protection from potential lawsuits, allowing us to freely share our faith."

                                         Kristi Donyes, Director of Operations, Bloom & Grow Childcare Center 


"I greatly value the high quality, cost-effective, comprehensive, insurance program offered by our American Church Group of Wisconsin agent, Larry Clinton, through Brotherhood Mutual Insurance Company. American Church Group of Wisconsin and Brotherhood Mutual will treat you like a true partner from start to finish. They will provide you with highly responsive, personal service, and a very cost-effective program to meet your insurance needs."  

George Zaferos, Business Administrator, St. Matthew's Lutheran Church & School


"The best part about working with our American Church Group of Wisconsin agents is their attention to detail and efficiency in service. They have worked with our church to offer cost effective options for policies with Brotherhood Mutual that have saved a substantial amount of money for our struggling budget. We are thankful for all they have done to ensure our church has the coverage it needs to continue our ministry."   

Erica Larson, Parish Admin/Worship Coordinator, Hope Lutheran Church


"I recently took over the oversight of insurance coverage for our church. Our American Church Group of Wisconsin agent, Jeff LaBelle, has been very patient helping me "get up to speed" on insurance related issues in my new position. He reviewed our policy with me and answered all my questions regarding specific pieces of the policy. He also regularly sends additional risk management resources and information we may want to consider. We have had a few claims—one of which was quite large—and they were all handled professionally and promptly."

Anne Tietsort, Parish Administrator, St. Luke's Lutheran Church